You are viewing lonewytch

Past | Future

amy/tardislight fairytale
In which the World Tree is blatant, the Tardis is a Goddess, Clara's lessons about Death continue, the Doctor is in denial, Clara is most certainly not an android and a million other very interesting things occur.

The World Tree and Tardis as Goddess
For a while I've been going on and on about World Tree symbolism in Moffat's Who, which, in this series, has become overt. The World Tree is a spiritual symbol found across many cultures and time periods, that uses the image of a Tree in order to depict life, the Universe and everything. It portrays the forces that make up reality, and the journey of living things within that reality.

In this episode, the Tardis herself is represented as containing a literal tree which has the ability to pattern particles and to create anything the user desires. For me, this core part of the Tardis symbolises that both the Tardis herself
is a symbol of the World Tree and that she is the equivalent of the force that creates the World Tree/Universe. She represents the force that lies behind reality. We're shown over and over in this episode, both in dialogue and in plot events, that the Tardis is a complex, living, creative, vastly powerful entity with infinite form, with the power to both create and destroy held in balance (also represented by the Eye of Harmony), a being with powers of a Goddess. That the Tardis represents the Goddess is also very relevant when it comes to looking at where this episode might fit in the structure of Joseph Campbell's Heroic Journey.

The circular Gallifreyan patterns behind the self-destruct countdown on the monitor resemble the structure and spheres of the Kabbalistic World Tree. The Kabbalistic World Tree, from the esoteric Judaic system,  depicts a series of spiritual principles in the form of spheres that are connected together in the abstract form of a Tree of Life. These principles describe how the Universe was created out of nothingness by the Divine, how the Divine can be discerned in the world around us,  the path of the human soul through reality, and how the soul ascends by becoming closer to the Divine. The Kabbalistic World Tree is essentially a map of God(dess), reality, the entire nature of the Universe and the role of living things within it. It's everything. Note the similarity between the circular Gallifreyan and the traditional depiction of the Tree.



The Tardis, as a Divine and infinite being, is able to contain within her the whole of reality. Her potential is endless, limitless. The journey our heroes make through her within the course of the episode are therefore a reflection of the nature of life and death.

The nature of the Tardis as a creative force is nowhere more evident that when we encounter the actual physical World Tree within her. This World Tree contains the potential to create everything that could be.

Sensor: Everthing.
Gregor: What? Report.
Sensor: Everything behind that door.
Gregor: What?
Sensor: Sensor detects everything you could possibly want.
Gregor: Give me a price tag.
Sensor: Incalculable.

I could barely contain my glee when Gregor opened the door on the word “everything” and lo and behold there was the World Tree in physical form.




Doctor: Architectural reconfiguration system. It reconstructs particles according to your needs.

The fruits/circuits of the tree are egg shaped (remember all the egg symbolism that was threaded through series 7a?), and eggs are of course a symbol of gestation, birth, new life. The Tardis World Tree is the essence of pure creation  -it has the power to effect reality in the form of reconstructing basic particles. It can create anything and everything. Not only that, it is a fundamental part of her own body. This is the power of a Goddess, the infinite power to create out of nothingness.

Each circuit/fruit/egg has circular Gallifreyan on it. The thing about circular Gallifreyan is that as a language it too represents the endless nature of reality, the principle of life/death/rebirth moving in a constant cyclical flow rather than a linear way. The very form of circular Gallifreyan is similar to the symbol of the Ouroboros, which is an extremely ancient symbol of a snake/serpent biting its own tail found across many cultures at different times It represented the cyclical nature of life and the ability to self-create.



Along with the Kabbalistic World Tree and the physical tree inside her, we have what - for us - has for so long been the heart of the Tardis; we have the Control Room and the Console. The Console and Time Rotor, extending from the ceiling down into the roots of the ship, and decorated with the cyclical images of circular Gallifreyan, physically resembles a tree in some ways. The Console/Time Rotor can be read as a symbolic World Tree, and the underneath of the Platform as the Underworld. One of the main themes we are dealing with in this episode is Death, and the Underworld is traditionally the ream of the Dead (notably in Norse mythlology, where the world of the Dead is located underneath the roots of the World Tree Yggdrasil.)

Gregor sends Bram off to strip the Console down, in a mirror of himself stealing the fruit/circuit of the World Tree. When Bram opens up the Tardis console, he begins to hear voices from the past spilling out. These voices lead him to the underneath of the platform, and then to prise open the belly of the ship. He discovers a hatch and a ladder that leads down alongside the roots of the Time Rotor. Ladders are often associated with Ascension in Who, but of course they also have a dual function and can be used as a bridge to transition between both Underworld and Upperworld. The Underworld is  the realm of the Dead -  this is where Bram literally ends up. His symbolic journey into the Underworld brings him face to face with a future dead version of himself, and makes the symbolic journey into a real one - when he himself ends up dead.




The Road of Trials and The Meeting With the Goddess
In the second stage of Joseph Campbell's Monomyth, which I’ve discussed in previous meta on series 7b, Clara has firmly left behind the Ordinary World, and is now fully in the Special Place - the world of the Doctor. This is the stage known as Initiation, and part of it is that the Hero has to undergo a series of trials and tests in order to win the prize which they have journeyed to the Special Place to gain, or to receive the lesson they have travelled there to learn. The tests that Clara have been facing so far have revolved mostly around the acceptance of her own mortality, and dealing with the fact that everything ends. Once again, in this episode, she is faced with this lesson.

When Clara lets the future version of herself in to the Tardis Control Room - shortly before she nearly dies - she stands facing herself across the Console. She and the dead version of herself look into each others eyes, and for a few moments they mirror each other's movements. She asks who the being is, and they stand face to face considering each other for a moment. In The Rings, Clara used the energy and acceptance of her mother's own mortality to vanquish the Sun God. In Cold War she faced the mortality of those around her as they were ripped to shreds by the Ice Warrior. In Hide she faced the conceptual idea that she was both dead and had never been born to the Doctor. There's been a definite progression in these lessons. Now, she at last comes face to face with her own dead self, literally.





Surely this is one of the hardest lessons of all? Acceptance of your own mortality; witnessing your own death and yet surviving.

Thing is, this lesson is taking place for all our characters in this episode. All of them face future dead versions of themselves. The brothers are consumed by it. The Doctor faces this lesson too - but what does he do in the face of it? He denies it.

Clara: You’re gonna tell me right now, if we’re gonna die here you’re going to tell me what they are!
Doctor: I can’t.
Clara: Tell me! What’s the use in secrets now?
Doctor: Secrets protect us. Secrets make us safe.
Clara: We’re not safe!

In my meta on The Rings of Akhaten, I talked about the fact that the reason Clara was able to vanquish the Sun God is precisely because she is a mortal, and she held in her hands the leaf which was the symbol of true life and death. The reason the Doctor could never win that battle is because his death/resurrection in the form of regeneration is not a true death. He does not - cannot - know death itself. In his current character arc, he cannot admit it, cannot face Clara's death as his actions here show. Clara, though, is miles ahead of him in accepting what has happened to her. After all, this is the precise lesson she has been working with now for the last few episodes.




Sensor: Sensor detects animal DNA. Human core element. Calculating data. Calculating data. Lancashire. South. Identifiable substance. Clara.
Clara: That’s me.
Doctor: I’m so sorry.
Clara: That’s me. I burn in here.
Doctor: It isn’t just the past leaking out through the Time rift, it’s the future. Listen, I brought you here to keep you safe, but it happened again. You died again.
Clara: What do you mean again?

She turns around and faces the dead version of herself through the porthole (again, remember all the porthole type images in Asylum?), and we see her face mirrored along with that of the future her.




Later, on the bridge between the Eye of Harmony room and the centre of the Tardis, alongside a yawning gulf, Clara receives her next lesson. It's partially about the acceptance of imminent death. However, for me it feels as if Clara has been through these now and proven herself 3 times over with the first half of the series. Here she finds out that he does not accept her for who she knows herself as. She learns that she may not really know herself. That there is something deeply unusual about her.

Clara: If you don’t have a plan we’re dead.
Doctor: Yes. We are. So just tell me.
Clara: Tell you what?
Doctor: Well, there’s no point now, we’re about to die. Just tell me who you are.
Clara: You know who I am!
Doctor: No I don’t. I look at you every day and I don’t understand a thing about you. Why do I keep running into you?
Clara: Doctor, you invited me, you said-
Doctor: Before, I met you at the Dalek Asylum, there was a girl in a shipwreck. She died saving my life, and she was you.
Clara: She really wasn’t.
Doctor: Victorian London, there was a governess who was really a barmaid, and we fought the Great Intelligence together, she died and it was my fault, and she was you!
Clara: You’re scaring me.
Doctor: What are you eh?  A trick? A trap?
Clara: I don’t know what you’re talking about!
(Clara nearly falls off the edge of the cliff, he grabs her and pulls her into his arms)
Doctor: You really don’t, do you?
Clara: I think I’m more scared of you right now than anything else on that Tardis.
Doctor: You're just Clara, aren’t you?

In some ways this is a mirror of the lesson that she faced  in Hide. There, the Doctor took her to the beginning and the end of the Earth, and she saw that to him she had both never been born, and was dead at the same time, that her bones were out there somewhere. Here, she finds out she is from both the past and future, and that for the the Doctor, both versions of her are dead.

Significantly here, in a mirror of his earlier reluctance to tell her that a future version of herself has dies on board the Tardis, she forgets these events and we don't see him remind her of them. This is problematic for him. Clara's not the only one on a journey to acceptance here.

We all know, that at the moment the Doctor has this huge thing going on about his name. He does not want his true name/identity to be revealed. For whatever reason he is symbolically unable to own and accept that part of himself. However, this is acting out in the form of him projecting this onto Clara by denying her the own ability to have self knowledge of her potential true nature. This is bad, because the Doctor, as the Hero's mentor, should be facilitating self knowledge. Yes, the mentor may challenge the Hero, may cloak the answer to the quest for self knowledge in puzzles and challenges...but to allow someone to forget the self knowledge they have gained? This is projection of his own issues onto her. Adn how can someone be a mentor and a doorway into self knowledge, when they are in such denial adout their own identity?

Interestingly, linking with this, in the comments to my meta on Hide, bloodpara asked me what my thoughts were on the fact that at the moment, the Doctor's sonic seems to be malfunctioning a lot. After some thought and some rambling, my answer was this, and I see now how it very very much links in with this denial and projection:

Hmm, the sonic screwdriver...that's a damn good point and not one i'd really thought of. On a mythic/archetypal level, the sonic is the equivalent of the wizard's magic wand. The psychic interface means it is literally controlled by the power of the mind and the will of the user. If it's malfunctioning, it'd suggest some type of gulf inside him that's widening, separating him from his will that usually allows him to accomplish the "good" things with the screwdriver. I'm sure this sliver of ice is linked to his name and identity. Psychologically, I'd say the Doctor is more and more aware he's coming to the point of revelation of his name and identity - but that it is shrouded in such deep darkness that he's in denial. He clearly wants to totally forget this dark secret at the heart of himself. Thing is, you can't deny your Shadow Self, you have to accept and embrace it - otherwise you aren't whole. Him running faster and faster from his name, means his identity is more and more fractured.

That was a lot of rambling, but i was thinking as i was typing! So yeah, i think him denying his true name as it draws closer is fracturing himself. To wield magic properly, a the wizard has to be in balance. That isn't possible when parts of the self are disowned. There's also a tradition of names granting power in fairy stories. If he won't accept his own name...really he's draining off one of the biggest sources of his own power :)


*

After, or intertwined with The Road of Trials stage of this second phase of the Monomyth, are a number of phases called the Meeting With the Goddess, Woman as Temptress and Atonement with the Father. This journey to the heart of this creative, infinite being can definitely be read as this stage.

Christopher Vogler in The Writer's Journey, a modern book dealing with the Monomyth, calls this whole stage the Ordeal and outlines how this stage is represented by some sort of an approach to an innermost cave, where the Hero encounters threshold guardians (the Tardis herself and the dead versions of the characters), where illusion is rife in order to seduce the Hero from the path (the Tardis
re-configuring the ship architecture), and where the stakes are higher than ever before (averting a visible future death). Joseph Campbell has this to say about this stage:

This is the crisis at the nadir, the zenith, or at the uttermost edge of the earth, at the central point of the cosmos, in the tabernacle of the temple, or within the darkness of the deepest chamber of the heart. The meeting with the goddess (who is incarnate in every woman) is the final test of the talent of the hero to win the boon of love (charity: amor fati), which is life itself enjoyed as the encasement of eternity. And when the adventurer, in this context, is not a youth but a maid, she is the one who, by her qualities, her beauty, or her yearning, is fit to become the consort of an immortal.

Christopher Vogler says this:
The simple secret of the Ordeal is this: Heroes must die so that they can be reborn.


Often in the Journey, the meeting with the Goddess occurs after the tests have been overcome, and is where the Hero experiences the power of love and finds peace and acceptance in the Universe. The thing with the Heroic Journey, is that the stages above don’t always happen in order and are sometimes mixed and blended together. It can be hard to discern, until the full narrative has played out, how a character is fitting into it. The thing that Clara finds at the heart of the Tardis is first death, and then rebirth. It’s both being alive and being dead at the same time – it’s the layers of life and time held together in the core of the Goddess. She wins the acceptance of the Doctor as he realises that she is a real girl, as much as Tricky is a real boy rather than an android. He, the immortal, accepts her as his “consort.”

One of the other (unfortunately named) stages close to the Meeting With the Goddess in Campbell's Monomyth is the Woman as Temptress stage. This is where the Hero encounters a moment of betrayal, crisis, abandonment or disappointment within this arena of Love. We have this represented here in the revelation of the Docotr's mistrust for her, and his betrayal of her confidence in misleading her about his true reasons for taking her with him.

Atonement with the Father...this is often the Hero's acceptance of the thing that holds ultimate power over their life. This is usually death, although it can be read at a superficial level as the Doctor currently having power over Clara's life as he  controls the times and places where she goes. This idea may develop in future episodes, but I;m going to hazard a guess that both Clara's acceptance as the future dead version of herself, and the Doctor's acceptance of her as a real girl link into this stage.


Lastly, to pass thruogh to the true inner sanctume of the Goddess require a leap of faith, a stepping out into a a chasm, as in the case of the Fool card of the Tarot's Major Arcana.



There's so much more I could write about the Monomyth here, but I am really out of time and energy. I'll just point out that the ultimate healing of the Tardis, and the avoidance of death is once again linked into the idea of song/music.

Doctor: I need to find the moment we crashed, I need to find…the music.

The Doctor uses the sonic to tune into the music that was playing at the moment they crashed in order to provide the Big Friendly Button they need to escape their fate. Song saves. Again.

(There is also a theme of the tolling of bells, with the Bells of Saint John in the first episode when the Tardis external phone rang, the Cloister Bell in the last episode, and now the Cloister Bell again in this episode.)

*

Odds and Ends of other stuff
This section is a bit of a race through other stuff I noticed....

Family
Family – the theme of family is here yet again. Is Moffat trolling us, or is Clara related to the Doctor?

Every single episode now seems to be hinting at some sort of family connection between them, with the constant theme of family present in each one. Here, in the supporting characters, we have a family member who is treated as something non-human. Tricky is someone who believes they are something other than they are. There is a very clear mirror between him and Clara and a link to the the way that the Doctor is conceiving of and treating Clara. He sees her as something non-human. He conceals facts about her identity from her, just as the Van Baalens are doing to their brother Tricky. Just as Tricky’s true identity as human is revealed to him, so Clra’s identity as something very strange indeed is revealed to her by the Doctor. She learns the truth of herself having died twice, and also learns the truth of what the Doctor truly suspects of her. In the end, just as Gregor finds his humanity and cannot kill Tricky by cutting his arm off, the Doctor accepts that Clara has no idea that she could be some type of trap, or that there have been other versions of her through time. He accepts her as Clara Oswald.

The Doctor

It’s the second time that he’s threatened to destroy something in order to get what he wants. It mirrors his actions in Cold War when he threatened to blow up the whole sub is the Ice Warrior set off a nuclear warhead. Now he threatens to blow up that which he loves the most, to destroy them all. It feels like this Doctor is on some type of symbolic self-destruct mission. As i mentioned above, I also believe that his own desire to avoid the revelation of his name, and that that symbolises his denial of self-knowledge, is causing him to project onto Clara and to deny her the ability to know herself. To some extent, there are elements of role reversal going on - Clara seems, to me, to be forging ahead in the lessons she is learning about mortality and acceptance, where the Doctor seems....stuck.

The Eyes Have It
Eye imagery was something we saw a lot of in early Moffat-era Who. The theme of seeing and perception was prevalent in series 5 particularly. It’s been there all the way through though, and there’s lots of it in this ep, from the eyes of Tricky, the android who isn’t an android, to the Eye of Harmony. Note, also, the red and blue tones throughout these images.

Considering the Tricky/Clara mirror, it's apt that his eyes and the veiw from them resemble the Dalek Oswin's views from within Asylum.


The magnetic field of the magna-grab looks like an eye.


The Galaxy on the cracking console screen is also eye like. Then, of course, there are the glowing red eyes of the future burned up selves of the characters. There are lights on the Tardis that resemble eyes, and which are, again, reminiscent of the many porthole and circularly framed shots in Asylum.




Lastly, there is also the Eye of Harmony, which is a juxtaposition of opposites. Decay held in stasis.



Doctor: The Eye of Harmony, exploding star in the act of becoming a black hole. Time Lord engineering, you rip the star from its orbit, suspend it in a state of permanent decay.


The X Motif
This is a symbol often used in Moffat’s Who and that I've written about often in the past. The X symbol is used in circumstances where there is some type of mirroring, connection, transaction of energy or crossing over going on. We see it here first behind the picture of the Van Baalen family, but with the android brother ripped off, we also see it as the Tardis appears on the monitors of the salvage vessel. The character mirror of Tricky/Clara and the idea of family connections links aptly to the use of this symbol here.



The Tardis also begins mirroring the Doctor and Clara back to themselves. As they make the journey to the centre of the Tardis, Clara again faces mirror versions of herself, just as she did in Hide. The rupture means that the Tardis is leaking the two of them through, recent things that they have done.Immediately after these instances of mirroring, the fuel rods start to snap and break through the wall, creating the X Motif.




Tardis Interior
Immediately after the crash, Clara lies underneath a circle in a square, and often used symbol of achieving the impossible and juxtaposition of opposites (yep, re-use of props, but the symbolism is there nonetheless.)



The colours of red and blue (fire and water) are all over the place and the first door she opens, opens onto fire. There are also fires burning in the Control Room.



The next thing she opens the door to after the fire is the room containing the Doctor’s cot, which was also Melody Pond’s cot for a short time. Then she puts her hands on  a Tardis model….is this the same model that Amy made, and which Mels once handled? She spins it round in her hands – in a way which very much reminded me of the way Mels handles the model in Let’s Kill Hitler. River's here again, in spirit.



After that, we see an observatory with what might be the telescope from Tooth and Claw that focuses moonlight???? Immediately after that it’s the swimming pool. There’s a link there between the power of moonlight and of water. Moonlight/water are both seen in occult terms as things associated with the subconscious, with memories, dreaming, with seeing things in a different light  - and also with death.



The next place she gets to is the Library. Echoes of River Song are very much here again. Especially since River is the only one who we know knows his name....until this moment when Clara discovers it. River reveals to him she knows his name in the Library where she dies. Clara discovers his name in the library where she encounters her dead self. Clara and River are mirrored.

 The bottled essence of the
Encyclopedia Gallifreya contains the infinity symbol.



There's links to the idea of echo Universes that was explored in Hide. The Tardis creates echoes of the Control Room to try and create a safe space for the people on the ship to be.  An echo is also a mirror

Doctor: It’s an echo…the Console Room is the safest room on the ship, it’s trying to protect us.

Doctor: There’s more than one echo room….it’s like a light switch flickering at super infinite speeds, we’re only together for a second.

Lastly, Moffat's little nod to his own storytelling. Since the start, Clara/Owsin seesm to have had the ability to break the fourth wall/threaten the narrative. We see it here, as she questions the type of myth the Doctor is.

Clara: What do you keep in here? Why have you got zombie creatures? Good guys do not have zombie creatures, rule one basic storytelling!

Thanks for reading.


Comments

( 32 comments — speak to me, sweetie )
fannishliss
May. 4th, 2013 12:38 pm (UTC)
This world tree stuff is fascinating. It does give my heart joy to see the world tree at the heart of the Tardis -- the way the tree is so overtly portrayed, with its fruit containing "Everything" -- AWESOME. :D I love that the Tardis is the Doctor's Wife.... In so many ways I would love for Clara to be the Doctor's Daughter, somehow the offspring of the Doctor and the Tardis... if the Tardis can create "Everything" can a daughter be one of those things? I keep coming back to her name... Clara - meaning of course, light, clarity, sight -- the aspect of the eye -- Oswin, meaning "Companion of God", and Oswald meaning "Rule of God." It's an incredibly loaded name -- but which god -- the Doctor, or the Tardis?? Clara might think that the Tardis doesn't "like" her, but maybe it's more of a mother-daughter thing?

I like the way you map Clara's journey onto the "monomyth." I have had my doubts as to the universality of the patriarchal monomyth (the Hero as young man faces young man trials like Woman as Temptress and Meeting the Father, whereas young women have uniquely womanly trials to face) -- but you do a very good job here with the more universal aspects of the monomyth. It is always good to see a diagnostic tool stretched to its limits. :)

I think these aspects of family and mirroring do hint at Clara's identity, and I can't wait to find out what it means. I also think there is something there with Clara's name being partly an anagram of CAL ---you just have to add Ra -- that big old sun that we keep seeing everywhere!!
fannishliss
May. 4th, 2013 12:39 pm (UTC)
sorry so long! that's what I get for including a long blockquote:
That image of a porthole leads to a very famous poem in praise of Holy Love, 1 Corinthians 13 :
1 Though I speak with the tongues of men and of angels, and have not love, I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. 2 And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not love, I am nothing. 3 And though I bestow all my goods to feed the poor, and though I give my body to be burned, and have not love, it profiteth me nothing. 4 ... 8 Love never faileth: but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away. 9 For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. 10 But when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away. 11 When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things. 12 For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known. 13 And now abideth faith, hope, Love, these three; but the greatest of these is Love.
----it's remarkable that in this very famous passage we have so many of the images from this episode -- the burned body, the darkened glass, the ringing gong. The progression from childhood to adulthood... Even the image of the Encyclopedia Gallifreya-- knowledge -- vanishing away in a wispy cloud of smoke. And the message, that Love Never Fails, was THE key message from Hide. What it hints at is the failure of prophecy when it goes up against the miraculous power of love. -- or, as it is revealed in this ep, the miraculous power of the Doctor, the Tardis, and Clara, to rewrite unwanted History that has already happened, to keep it from Happening Again.

Is that how there can be a Written History of the Time War??? There are only two entities who could have written such a history -- the Doctor -- maybe his Name is on the Title page -- or the Tardis herself, except that she does not speak in Words/Logos. That book would be the Rule of the Father, would it not?

Several of my friends are very afraid that Moffat is planning to rewrite the Doctor's History. Out of great respect to existing canon, I hope that's not true.... but there is an aspect to all this that signifies a return to the Doctor's very beginnings, back before his name was Stricken. (I follow the Cartmel plan btw). The Doctor's life as we know it has been lived in a linear fashion -- but there is a mystery at his origin, involving his Name, that seems more Ouroboros than linear.

Well, thanks very much for your very insightful readings. Cheers!

May the Fourth be with you!
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 11:54 am (UTC)
<3<3<3

I have a lot of love for the way you've related that biblical quote back to the ep. Previous series have seen a lot of pagan imagery, but there's been a lot of drawing on the Abrahamic religions this half of the series - the unspeakable name of god, the kabbalic world tree etc. I also like the theme you point out of prophecy failing when it goes up against love. This suggests love will save the day (Love/Death so often present in Moff's Who), but like you pint out, timelines that have already been played out are something that can be overcome by Love. Back to the Library?

Yeah, it's an interesting question who write the book. We do know that the tree can make anything/everything though. Can i produce books as well as machines? Could the Doctor have programmed her to produce a book (him as the conduit for the Tardis expressing in words)

Hmmm, i don't know if Moff will rewrite his history. Then again, i say that, but Moff as said that the finale into 50th will radically change the direction of Who forever. Do you think we are heading towards the revelation of the Doctor as the "Other" (links in with the name, as the Other is nameless, right?)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 11:45 am (UTC)
Squee, thnak you for such a lovely and long comment!!!

I agree, i would totally adore for Clra to somehow be their daughter...the next best thing though? Clara as the daughter of 11 and River - the child of the Tardis. Ah well, a girl can dream! Could be the case though. the family connection - it's there in every ep. The River subtext, there in every ep. I think we're def moving towards some type of family-like connection between them.

If you're interested in a more more modern interpretation of the Monomyth that moves away from some of the sexist and genderbinary terms Campbell uses, i'd strongly recommend the book The Sacred Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers by Christopher Vogler. I refer back to Campbell a lot as peeps are more familiar with him and it's easy to ref the wiki article for people, but Vogler's book very much updates the use of the myth and the archetypes and stretches them further.

I also think there is something there with Clara's name being partly an anagram of CAL ---you just have to add Ra -- that big old sun that we keep seeing everywhere!!

Okay...mind blown. It's a great point. I would die of joy if Clara was a post-Library River.
hawkmoth
May. 4th, 2013 12:44 pm (UTC)
Mind.Blown.Again.

(ETA: World Tree! In the TARDIS!)

The visuals in this episode were amazing. Not just the special places we saw within the TARDIS, but the color schemes, the positioning of things...the details!

Books and storytelling and myths and legends have been key features of the episodes so far. I love it.

(I love the fact that after the use of the BFB, with time supposedely reset, the Van Baalen family portrait was restored to include Tricky.)

So, did River write The History of the Time War?

The Doctor running from his name seems to mirror when he was, well, not running from, but delaying his arrival at Lake Silencio for the appointement that had to be kept. He also seems to be more frantic than ever before (though it'a hard to tell with Matt's portrayal!) and as you say, becoming more and more fractured.

However far he fell at Demon's Run, we may see him fall further and deeper by the time the season ends.

Edited at 2013-05-04 12:47 pm (UTC)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 11:58 am (UTC)
Hee! Thank you, glad you enjoyed!

I know, i thought the set design was totally spectacular.

History of the Time war...i suggested to a commentor above that maybe the Tree produces things other than machines, maybe the Doctor could have programmed the Tardis to produce the book. The only ones who could have are him, the Tardis - or Rive rif she is in some way released from the Library.

Agree with you about the Silencio mirror. He ran from his death, now in a way he's running from whatever he did in his life past. The man who can die/resurrect running from both life and death, which kind of fits my argument that regeneration is not true death and rebirth, and Clara is currently way ahead of him on her personal journey to accept mortality and rebirth.
promethia_tenk
May. 4th, 2013 01:10 pm (UTC)
I like it when you say things <3
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 11:58 am (UTC)
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed!
xxx
vernzo
May. 4th, 2013 01:42 pm (UTC)
I loved reading your meta, it makes me love watching Doctor Who all the more. Sometimes it gets really hard with all the negativity I come across. So... thanks!
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 11:59 am (UTC)
Aw, thank you, that makes me so happy to hear if i makes you enjoy the show more. Yeah, i'm not into the negativity either, doing meta as a labour of love is my shield against it!
rhoda_rants
May. 4th, 2013 03:38 pm (UTC)
I love this. No time to say more now, but I'll be back after work...

ETA: Okay, back after reading more carefully and taking a look at some of your other metas. You are brilliant, first of all, and I deeply admire the dedication and enthusiasm you have for putting such a balanced, thorough analysis together. Beyond that, however, I've never thought to approach Doctor Who from a mythic/archetypal angle before, at least to the extent that you've done here. I loved this episode--it's right up there with "The Doctor's Wife" as one of my all-time favorites for 11's run, and I've been a bit dismayed to see so many fans trashing it because of logic, or continuity errors, or other things that are supposed to be impossible. And even though I understand the why behind a lot of the criticisms that were made, none of that stuff really bothered me, and I haven't been able to put my finger on why.

Having read this meta, I know now: it's the journey. I love tricksters archetypes for one thing, and while I didn't see Clara as a trickster before, I think you're absolutely right. The other thing I started thinking about is the labyrinth as a strong archetypal image--and another one of my favorite things ever. (I have one on a keychain.) The TARDIS in this episode feels like a labyrinth, not just because of the way the characters get spun around inside it, but because of the journey it takes them on. Because the labyrinth, in my favorite use of the image, isn't a maze--not really. It's not a place to get lost and trapped in. It's the means by which the traveler goes on a journey of meditation, reflection and ultimately enlightenment, starting at the outer rims and going closer and closer to the center. That's exactly what happens here--Clara uncovers the truth behind the Doctor's name, faces her own death, recovers from it leaving her fear behind her and with a clearer sense of her own identity, then ultimately travels to the center of the TARDIS where all things end and begin simultaneously.

I was upset by the way the Doctor reset things at the end--he's not ready to face his own fears about his identity, and erases the events of the day. However, I have a feeling (or maybe just a hope) that somewhere inside Clara's unconscious is the memory of that journey, and they're both going to need it before this run is over. See, the other thing this reminds me of is the second Silent Hill game, just a little bit. I don't know if you're familiar, but there's a huge theme in Silent Hill of facing your demons--all your guilt, fear, doubts, etc.--in the form of literal demons, monsters that you have to fight through in this hellish Otherworld setting. In the second game, it's only after James taps into memories that he suppressed and comes to terms with what he did that the player (depending on their actions earlier on--there are a lot of variables) can defeat the final boss and end the game. I feel like that's what Clara's story is leading to--she's the key to the Doctor facing his own inner demons and vanquishing them, but he has to accept them first, and in this episode he's not ready to do that yet.

Edited at 2013-05-05 01:44 pm (UTC)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:15 pm (UTC)
Aw, thank you so much for the totally fab comment! First off, i'm really touched by how much you've enjoyed my writing. I feel totally compelled to do it, though sometimes it's a bit of a labour of love, so it's totally lovely when people really enjoy and appreciate it.

I've not really encountered bashing of this ep, but where i see the negativity start i tend to steer clear of it, because i want to keep my squee. I think this is one of the things at the crux of Moff's Who though- he's such a vastly different showrunner to RTD, and his entire approach is very mythic, so it rally lends itself to this type of analysis. Things that are more symbolically and mythically based sometimes do sacrifice logic a little more, because that isn't their key focus, and i think some criticism of Moff's Who stems from this. I adore RTD by Moff's Who suits my watching and interpreting style better precisely because of the heavy symbolism.

Toootally agree with you about the Labyrinth symbol ,and Tardis as Labyrinth, for exactly the reasons you describe. It's the journey into the centre, to the darkness (minotaur) at the core, with death/mortality/shadow self as the ultimate darkness at the centre. You can never be lost in the Labyrinth, it only appears that you're lost. (other outings of the idea are in the God Complex, and also the Maze of the Dead in The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone. I have meta on the Angles eps if you dig back - River Song is actually the only one who refers to the Maze of the Dead as a Labyrinth in that ep, and she's playing the role of the dark goddess Hecate.)

I do agree with you that the things the Doctor has allowed Clara to forget will resurface. His name, for one...it makes me now think that she will be the one to speak his name. The thing is, I think in some way he is going to have to pay for denying Clara her own self knowledge, because i don't think as her archetypal mentor he can just do that. He's so damn desperate to not admit to himself the darkness of his own past, that he is denying hers, and these things have a way in stories of coming back and slapping people in the face.

I'm not familiar with Silent Hill, but i know where you're coming from. Totally agree - Clara will act as a mirror to reflect back the Doctor's demons/shadow to him. The fact that Doctor Who? is very much tied up with "Clara Who?" is intriguing.

a_phoenixdragon
May. 4th, 2013 04:13 pm (UTC)
The swimming pool and the library being so close together tickled me...

(Sorry had to mention that)

As always, you have made clear what was previously foggy. You have brought me near tears and made me wanna write furiously, even as you have already laid everything out to perfection and there is nothing more that can be said...

Thank you for this. Gods, I love your metas!!

*hugs you hard*

Edit: I must also say - as the Doctor's self fractures, as he loses his own identity as he KNOWS IT NOW while running from an ancient truth - his reality follows. He can no longer see truth from fiction. He is terrified of his Companion even as he is intrigued. It runs deeper than his name, I think. He has lost all ability to see beyond the mask he has made for himself...

There is a ficcy thought there.

Edited at 2013-05-04 04:15 pm (UTC)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:19 pm (UTC)
I loooooved the library so much. Librarian me wend "SQUEEEEEE!!!"

Aw darlin,thank you so much and i;m so glad you enjoyed the meta!!!

Agree with you - the situation with Clara is totally reflective of his own fear about the shadows in his past and the meaning of his name. Like her shadow haunting him across past and future, so his own identity does. So he does with Clara exactly what he does with his own name - holds it close, keeps its darkness secret, is terrified to admit it. These things have a dreadful way of biting back. The fact that he is denying Clara self knowledge due to projecting his own issues troubles me deeply. This is not who he is, he's the mentor, the guide, the good wizard to the companions (or at least, should be with a new-ish companion). It's deeply selfish and all generated through fear.
radiolaires
May. 4th, 2013 04:21 pm (UTC)
It's brilliant! Very dense and wonderfully full of mythology.

I could not help thinking about you and your use of the World Tree when this luminescent beauty appeared on the screen.
What also struck me is that the tree is here a thing, creating things, so not life, eggs for things. And similarly the Library was all wood -dead trees- and death/memories of long gone people -forest of the dead indeed-, with bottles containing voices, as fossilised eggs for people. (That said I just realised maybe Clara managed to read the book because she had absorbed some of the content of the bottle...) So when are we going to have a tree that is a tree, alive and not gloomy?

About the Doctor's identity, he really is on a self-destruction path... The TARDIS was on auto destruct, her heart exploded and was fixed in stasis; he has a sliver of ice in his hearts... Could we assume he did as the TARDIS?

Also I wondered what you made of the fact the boundary protecting the centre of the TARDIS was a river/cliff.
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:32 pm (UTC)
Thank you ~happy dance~ So glad you enjoyed!

Oooh, i see your link from the tree to the Library on the ship and the bottles voices. Also, parallel to the Tardis cpnsole and Time Rotor which symbolises the Wrld Tree, and the voice from the past issuing forth from it when Bram prises it open.

Thing is the World Tree is life/death in one. I think we had the tree as a symbol of life as well as death in the Rings of Akhaten - at least at the start of the ep, when the leaf from the tree is the thing that brings two people together in love in order to create life. I'm not conveinced we will ever see the tree as an exclusive symbol of joy, as this era of Who imagery around trees is so very very much tied into the idea of afterlife, death and rebirth.

About the Doctor's identity, he really is on a self-destruction path... The TARDIS was on auto destruct, her heart exploded and was fixed in stasis; he has a sliver of ice in his hearts... Could we assume he did as the TARDIS?
OOOH, yes yes yes!!That's a great mirror! It's like when he said the Tardis had frozen the moment and it was only a matter of time - it's the same for him, this total denial of who he is is only frozen temporarily, and ulitmately the ice will melt and he will implode. Also makes me think of the fact that Clara was the one who made the snow melt through her tears. So she will be key to the melting/implosion.

Well, the cliff, if we continue the above reading of the frozen heart of the Tardis as a symbol of the Doctor's frozen heart....
This could be symbolic of the gulf he has tried to create within himself between the person he wants to be and the dark secret tied to his name. He has pushed that self-knowledge across a gap so broad he can justify not dealing with it. Thing is, this gap is illusory in the Tardis, all it requires is a step out into the unknown (see the image of the Fool Tarot card which often depicts the Hero figure at the start of a journey, just about to step off a cliff.) Equally, the gap is illusory in himself. We can't ever deny who we are, the gulf is not impassable, it will take a huge act of courage and faith for him to step across his own gap to the core of who he is and find a way to melt that slover of ice at his heart.

Thanks for commenting!!!
radiolaires
May. 8th, 2013 10:22 pm (UTC)
What I meant was a tree-tree with leaves, not falling and browning, but green and in bloom, not a thing-tree -I'm not making any sense. But, yes, we will probably have to wait a little longer in order to see a happy tree.

Yes to Clara as the melting power!

Everything you wrote about the sliver of ice and his hearts and Clara was perfect, absolutely; it's a miny meta commentary, thank you very much!
Agnes Maria
May. 6th, 2013 02:54 am (UTC)
re: Sliver of Ice
Regarding will / control (great bit about the screwdriver malfunction btw):

Clara in the Victorian Era was able to melt the snow but not the ice. Lovely sweet and heavy symbolism in that; it is part of her lesson ;)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:35 pm (UTC)
Re: Sliver of Ice
Good point - and the step has to be taken by him (the step into the illusory chasm, the void) in order fr him to melt his own sliver of ice. Nobody can force self-accpetance onto another person, that's a path he has to walk himself. I wish he would give her a chance to accept herself by allowing her to know what he knows about her. There could be a powerful lesson in that for him, but it's too close to the core of his own issues.
elisi
May. 6th, 2013 08:21 am (UTC)
Keep meaning to write something and then get sidetracked. So all I'll say is - I read, and I liked. The show is just too darn DENSE at the moment, it's rather like wandering through a thicket in a forest...
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:36 pm (UTC)
No worries, I know how it is, i've spend hours on LJ this morn trying to catch up with everyone on my flist whose thoughts i love, there's just so many thoughts!!!

I agree with you, it's hugely dense, fitting though as we're getting towards the apex of the core question. Plus, forest metaphor for the win!!!!
gratiela
May. 6th, 2013 06:57 pm (UTC)
I've bee reading your wonderful meta for a while now, and each time I'm too in awe to actually say anything<3
I think you manage make it clear just why I love Doctor Who so much, pointing out to so many subtle(or not so subtle:D) details and symbols that make these stories so rich, so empowering, so enlightening!

Thank you!

PS: Do you mind if I friend you?
(I mean, I could just track your entries, but I feel it would be a much nicer feeling, this friending business :D)

Edited at 2013-05-06 07:01 pm (UTC)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:39 pm (UTC)
Aw, thank you so much, it's so lovely of you to comment. It really means a lot when people stop by to tell me how much they enjoyed reading. Also, totally agree with you about Doctor Who being enlightening.

The other day at work (i'm a librarian) i found myself ending a conversation by wagging a finger at another librarian and (almost) shouting "And that is why Doctor Who is a tool for self growth!!!". When fannishness and real life collide!

Yep ,please do add me! It is much nicer business. I'll add you too!!
goingbronco
May. 7th, 2013 04:34 am (UTC)
Love me some Doctor Who, how fun to read :)
lonewytch
May. 8th, 2013 12:40 pm (UTC)
Aw, thank you, really glad you enjoyed, and thank you for commenting!!!
boji
May. 11th, 2013 01:57 am (UTC)
With Moff's nods (sub textually) to eyes I have found myself wondering if any of this links back to Classic Who. Now, I know very little of the original, but Googling reveals all kinds of interesting things.


Re the bottles in the library, in the spin-off Who books there were, apparently, whole universes in a bottle. And the most important image of an eye may not be the eye of harmony but the untempered Schism. What did the Doctor see, when he was eight? What has he been running from ever since?

LOVE that you link the symbolism inherent in this episode with the TAROT.
lonewytch
May. 20th, 2013 11:52 am (UTC)
Oooh, I've seen some classic Who but the bottled Universes are something I didn't know. That moment in the Library with whishpers spilling out of the bottle reminded me oddly of the chamber where all the prophecies are kept in Harry Potter (Order of the Phoenix, was it?)

Yeah, the Untempered Schism... I've always wondered what the Doctor saw when he looked inside that. The Eye of Harmony - presumably there was one located in each Tardis, is almost a symbolic mirror of that I guess. I'm having half formed thoughts about that. The Schism is a fundamental part of Timelord Initiation, and it made them what they were. Thoughts will not compute.

It was when he was stood on the edge of that cliff, and i was like "Tarot!!!" I am pretty sure there are some other uses of Tarot in this ep too, ubt i haven't had time to delve into it yet.
mr_squiddle
May. 16th, 2013 06:12 pm (UTC)
Since you called in the Kabbalry (I wish I could CC: janie-aire on this):

Van Baalen Bros -- is that Baal as in Baal Shem?

"His name is the Doctor" indeed...
lonewytch
May. 20th, 2013 11:55 am (UTC)
Fantastic catch!!!!! Really, never got that at all. The link is perfect. Have you sene the finale?

if not, a spoiler follows.....


River is the only one who both knows and willingly uses his name. So she would be like his Baal Shem - the priestess who speaks the word, and who has a direct line to him as an echo that is always with him.
starry113
May. 18th, 2013 07:11 am (UTC)
Lovely meta, I noticed a lot of the world tree stuff going on as well.
I am, however, going to disagree with you on Clara's scene in the library being a mirror to River in the library, a reference perhaps but not a mirror. This is because if you go back and pay close attention to each of the burnt selves the one that chases Clara in the library is in fact the Doctor (indicated by hand over the face).
lonewytch
May. 20th, 2013 11:57 am (UTC)
Thank you, glad you enjoyed!

Yeah, i agree with you there actually. I think the reference is still there especially with Clara seeing his name in the Libraty, but it's a dead Doctor who is chasing her.

Thanks for reading.
(Deleted comment)
( 32 comments — speak to me, sweetie )